Can MVPs Actually Be Effective?

The term “Minimum Viable Product” has taken a beating in recent years. Critics claim it’s outdated, vague, or invites mediocrity. But done right, an MVP remains one of the most effective tools for validating problem-solution fit. The problem isn’t with the concept of an MVP; it’s with how it’s misunderstood and misapplied. A well-defined MVP is still the best way to prove you’re solving a real problem, for real users, with a real solution.

Five Fast Takeaways

  • MVP ≠ prototype: MVPs are real products, not just experiments or tests.

  • Your riskiest assumption is the gateway: Validate desirability before building.

  • Define “winning” before shipping: What level of usage proves you solved the problem?

  • Viability has two meanings: Before building viability in the business and financial model sense, you must validate viability in the MVP sense.
  • Building a crappy MVP wastes time: MVPs must work well enough to deliver clear value.

Highline Beta Perspective: An MVP Without Value is a Test

We've seen countless founders struggle to define or execute on an MVP – not because the concept is broken, but because it's misunderstood. At Highline Beta, we coach startups to focus on validating problems before touching code. That means customer interviews, behavioral observations, and assumption testing with throwaway prototypes. Only once we have real evidence of desirability do we move forward. 

Too often, founders confuse MVPs with marketing tests; a landing page won’t prove that your product works. It might prove interest, but not stickiness or retention. So our bar is simple: if it can’t be used to solve the problem, it’s not an MVP. The MVP is not the first experiment; it’s the first thing that actually delivers value. With that definition in mind, we still believe MVPs can be an effective tool for startups, and should continue to be used as such.

FAQ

Q: What does “viable” really mean?
A:
Viable = users adopt, use, and pay - either with money, data, or attention. Without that, it’s not proving value.

Q: Can MVPs be complex?
A: Yes. Sometimes “minimum” still requires complexity - if that’s the smallest version needed to prove value.

Interested in Using Our PRD Template?

Access a Copy of It Here.

Want the Full Deep Dive?

Read the full article on Focused Chaos

Thanks for reaching out. Be sure to check us out on LinkedIn for all of our current news and announcements.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.